Payfederate logo cropped
Managing and Correcting Pay Compression: A Step-by-Step Guide for HR Professionals

Managing and Correcting Pay Compression: A Step-by-Step Guide for HR Professionals 

By Sam Reeve, CCP, GRP 

 

In the constantly changing U.S. labor market, pay compression has emerged as a significant challenge for HR and compensation professionals. This phenomenon, often a byproduct of rapid market changes and hiring practices, leads to minimal differences in pay between new hires and more experienced employees, potentially causing morale issues and legal concerns. This guide provides a roadmap for identifying and addressing pay compression effectively. 

Step 1: Conduct a Comprehensive Pay Analysis 

Begin by thoroughly analyzing your current pay structure. Assess the salaries of all employees, focusing on the variation in pay for similar roles and experience levels. A crucial aspect is to compare the wages of long-term employees with those of recent hires. 

Recently, one of my clients, a prominent software company, undertook a company-wide salary review. In their analysis, they identified that new software engineers were starting at salaries close to those of their experienced counterparts. This discovery was crucial for them to move forward with strategizing appropriate corrections.  

Step 2: Develop a Strategy for Pay Adjustment Aligned with Company Philosophy 

After identifying areas of pay compression, devise a salary adjustment strategy that aligns with your company’s overarching pay philosophy. This approach should consider factors like employee tenure, performance, and competence level. Focus on adjusting the salaries of longer-tenured employees, high performers, and those demonstrating superior competence in their roles. 

It’s crucial to ensure that these adjustments are significant enough to effectively resolve the compression issue. Moreover, consider the cascading effect these changes may have on higher-level positions, ensuring that the salary structure remains coherent and equitable across the organization. This holistic approach ensures that salary adjustments contribute positively to the company’s overall compensation objectives and employee morale.  

Step 3: Implement Pay Transparency and Continuously Update Pay Scales 

Integrating pay transparency into your compensation strategy is crucial. Clearly communicate the pay ranges for different roles and the criteria for salary increases, fostering a culture of openness and fairness. At the same time, make it a priority to continuously monitor market trends and update your pay scales accordingly. This dual approach of transparency and responsiveness helps manage employee expectations and ensures that your compensation structure remains competitive and equitable. 

Regularly updating pay scales in line with market conditions also aids in preventing future instances of pay compression. By being transparent about these changes and the rationale behind them, you not only maintain a competitive edge in the job market but also build trust and commitment among your workforce.  

Step 4: Educate Management and Talent Acquisition Teams on Pay Range Adherence 

Ensuring that managers and talent acquisition teams understand and adhere to established pay ranges is crucial in preventing pay compression and maintaining pay fairness. Education and training should emphasize the importance of staying within these ranges. This practice not only helps in avoiding pay discrepancies but also ensures that the compensation policy is consistently applied across all levels and departments. 

Managers should be encouraged to view these pay ranges not as restrictions, but as tools to maintain internal equity and market competitiveness. It’s important for them to understand how deviating from these ranges can lead to pay compression, potentially impacting employee morale and leading to legal risks. 

Additionally, encourage management to proactively engage in compensation discussions. If they believe the current pay ranges are not competitive enough to attract top talent, they should request special compensation studies. These studies can provide valuable insights and potentially lead to adjustments in pay scales, ensuring the company remains competitive in the talent market while adhering to equitable compensation practices. This proactive approach fosters a collaborative environment where pay decisions are made transparently and with a clear understanding of their broader impact. 

Step 5: Document and Review Decisions 

Maintain detailed records of all compensation decisions and the rationale behind them. This documentation is crucial for auditing purposes and in demonstrating compliance with equitable pay practices. 

Correcting pay compression is a multifaceted process that requires ongoing attention and adaptation. By implementing these strategies, HR professionals can not only address existing pay compression but also lay the foundation for a more equitable and transparent compensation system. This approach not only enhances employee satisfaction but also aligns with the ethical and regulatory standards, ensuring a robust and fair compensation framework within your organization.